A good friend of mine told me they had been summoned to jury duty. Reminded me of when I went. This post was written some time last year…
A few weeks ago I received a questionnaire in the mail from the Brooklyn court system. Now, no one has accused me of being overly attentive to details, but I distinctly remember reading “this is not a jury summons. If you fill out this questionnaire, you will not be summoned for jury duty.” I filled it out, placed it in the mail and congratulated myself for dodging my civic duty.
About a week later I received something that looked similar to the questionnaire. However, this time it was lacking the word “not” in reference to being summoned for jury duty. Had the court system lied to me? Was I being punished for my timely response? Either way, there was no avoiding it now…I had to serve jury duty.
The night before jury duty my mother suggested this would be a great opportunity to serve this great country’s judicial system. When I told her that was a load she said “well, at least you’ll get one or two good stories out of this”. I decided not to let the situation go to waste and decided to keep a running diary.
8:48 -
I arrive at the court and sit in a large room with roughly 80 other people. Not one of these people wants to be here and everyone is formulating ways to get dismissed early.
9:14 -
A woman wearing a blue blazer that is roughly 8 sizes too big comes out of some closet and pushes play on a VCR behind the clerics desk. The video starts with a dozen dirty peasants dressed in medieval garb standing by a river. After everyone watching the video is sufficiently confused the narrator says “Back in 14th century Europe, the law was settled by methods that were cruel and unusual.” This is when someone who is tied up gets thrown into the river and the narrator continues “If he floats, he is guilty…if he sinks, innocent”.
9:23 -
The video ends without getting less weird. Having three hundred people tell me how important jury duty is doesn’t make me feel any better about sitting next to some fat guy eating a danish the size of my head.
9:45 -
More instructions. I notice the guy sitting to my right is wearing a suit that looks like it’s made out of carpet.
10:13 -
The guy with the carpet suit starts talking to me about anything he can think of. He shows me pictures of his family, tells me about the competition his son won for having great abs and even tells me that in his native country, Russia, his wife is considered very attractive.
12:11 -
I notice a sign that says “If you are experiencing a problem, i.e. broken pay phones, untidy restrooms, etc., please contact…” I’ve already read this sign about 300 times, but then I notice that “untidy” is written on white tape and is obviously covering something. What is it covering? Poopy?
12:32 -
Things are starting to move now and I get to see my fellow jurors in action. I watch this conversation in horror:
Girl – “you have to sit in the second row”
Guy – (pointing to the second row) “Here?”
Girl – “Yes”
Guy – “Thank you” (goes and sits in last row)
1:02 -
Lunch. I have yet to get out of my chair since I sat down this morning. The only effort I have given was in trying to ignore the Russian guy wearing the carpet. I’m feeling sorry for myself. How can I tell? Well, that seems to be what’s going on whenever I get nothing for lunch but a root beer and listen to guilty pleasures like Abba, Boston, and Kylie Minogue on a bench somewhere!
2:38 -
My name is called into a juror interview room. I’m sitting there with 7 other people and we are being asked questions to see if we are suitable jurors. The first person questioned admits that he has been sued three times for beating the crap out of people. Dismissed.
2:42 -
When asked “what do you think of our legal system” I reply “I think getting thrown into a river would save all of us a lot of time”.
4:37 -
Somehow I make the final cut and am asked to come back tomorrow. I was pretty sure claiming to have no faith in our judicial branch of the government would be a good way to raise the “don’t pick me” flag, but somehow they liked me more than the woman who said she was surprised only one of the lawyers was jewish.
5:43 -
On my way home I buy one of those huge 1/2 gallon containers of ice cream and BBQ chips. Hmmm….I wonder if I’m still feeling sorry for myself?
Day 2:
8:12 -
I never really considered there being a day 2, but here it is. I feel refreshed and have a new attitude. Instead of feeling sorry for myself, I’m feeling invincible. When I walk into the court room, I’m the only one who can’t be wrong. The lawyers are kissing my ass, the judge is kissing my ass. If I want to set a criminal free, who is going to stop me?
9:43 -
I don’t know how it happened, but the Russian guy with the carpet suit is on the same jury as me. I spend the next thirty minutes having a conversation with the guy where I’m saying things like, “You have a Toyota? No way?” and “That does sound like a big breakfast”.
10:57 -
I feel depressed seeing a guy walk up and down the isles because he’s wearing this tight black t-shirt and has a large enough gut where 3-4 inches hangs out at all times. I’m thinking either this guy put on his son’s shirt this morning by accident or he’s in total denial about this gut that he’s growing.
1:43 -
We’re told to go home because the attempt at a settlement has failed and the case will go to trial. I mentally make note that this waste of time wouldn’t have happened down by the river.
Day 3:
9:21 -
The woman in the oversized blazer is repeating the same speech for the third day in the row. She sounds more depressed today than usual and I’m half expecting her to stop half-way through, tip over the desk and walk out.
10:12 -
A woman sitting near me asks me what my hobbies are. I say, “Jury Duty”.
12:37 -
We are taken into a small room without windows. There we are told to sit, be quiet and wait till someone comes to get us. The court officer locks the door behind him and I start looking around to figure out who we should kill to preserve oxygen.
1:21 -
The court officer returns and tells us to go to lunch. I’m not sure how good his sense of humor is so I refrain from saying “thanks for letting my practice my homicidal thoughts”.
2:14 -
While waiting in the lobby for the elevator I notice a sign that says “Save Water”. I have no idea why the sign is in quotation marks.
2:31 -
As we start opening statements I realize there is going to be a problem.
I can’t take my eyes off the stenographer. I obviously don’t understand short hand because he seems to be keeping right along while looking completely bored. Somehow I convince myself that I will be able to figure out short hand by watching him.
3:49 – After both councilors give their opening statements we are ushered back into our bomb shelter for a recess. As we are sitting in silence, one of the jurors claims the plaintiff has “selective retardation”. When another juror asks him to explain the first juror says “you know, it’s like, you can be retarded when you want to be”. This leads me to think times in my life I would WANT to be retarded.
4:10 -
The plaintiff calls his first witness. It’s a neurologist who is unbelievably well spoken. I feel like i should interrupt the proceedings to inform the witness of the conversation we just had about selective retardation.
4:13 -
The first objection!! Granted, it’s not as heated and the judge’s response isn’t as swift, but I can’t help but get excited whenever someone says objection.
4:53 -
Time to wrap up for the day. Tomorrow promises to be a full day and there is a pretty good chance it won’t be the last. The price of justice costs roughly 4-5 days of my time.
Day 4:
9:21 -
We jump right into the second witness. It’s the guy who was in the accident. He seems nervous – nervous enough to forget the names of his children. I guess when his lawyer suggested he “start him off with something easy” he should have started with “is this hot or cold?”.
9:22 -
The second question is “how old were you at the time of the accident”. Witness answers “I was turning 40 so I guess I was 29″. After a few minutes of confusion it is resolved when both councilors concede the witness is an idiot.
9:23 -
The third question is “How old were you when you first started getting treatment”. Witness answers “well, I’m almost 50 now so I was…younger”. The Plaintiff calls for a recess and we are ushered into our room.
9:32 – While we are in our room, one of the jurors points out that the lawyer for the defendant has a large head…like a pumpkin. I try to read my book while three of the jurors have an animated discussion over whether he should be called “Mr. Pumpkin Head” or simply “Pumpkin Head”.
10:45 -
The witness has become emotional on several occasions when describing the pain and anguish he went through because of this accident. I feel for the guy, I really do, but when he lists “Dominos” as an activity he can’t do because his knee hurts, I want to push the guy out of his chair.
11:21 -
Plaintiff rests. The defendant calls a neurologist of his own. The doctor starts by stating “I come from a country that some people call Ghana”. I’m eager to stop the trial and ask “what do other people call it?”
1:11 -
As I walk by the supreme court house I notice a big production crew. Must be shooting a movie, I thought. I was right. I saw Adam Sandler and that fat guy who isn’t funny and has a wife that’s way too hot for him on that show “King of Queens”. In front of the court house is a staged protest with signs that say “It’s Adam and Eve, NOT Adam and Steve!!”
As I’m watching this scene two rotund ladies walk by and have the following conversation:
Chub 1 – Oh look. A protest!
Chub 2 – It’s the homosexuals!
Chub 1 – Isn’t that Adam Sandler?
Chub 2 – Oh shit! He’s gay?!
2:10 -
When we get back from lunch I see that the juror who came up with selective retardation is still joking about how the judge has peed in the water we have provided. Somehow, this is still getting laughs.
3:23 -
After the final witness we are sent home to prepare for tomorrow which will entail closing arguments and the verdict.
Day 5:
9:12 -
I notice that both the lawyers have been wearing the same suit for the past four days. Not today, however. Today they have on what I’m sure they refer to as their “lucky suit”. Well, I’m going to go on a limb and say the guy with the green suit might want to think of buying a new one.
10:32 -
Closing arguments are done and we are sent into our room for deliberation.
11:53 -
We have come to a unanimous decision. No damages rewarded to the guy who doesn’t remember his kids names and who can no longer play dominos.
12:43 -
We have to fill out some paper work even talk to the lawyers for a few minutes to give them pointers and let them know how we arrived at our decision. I can tell that the lawyer who lost is questioning the legal system when one of the jurors said “If he hurt his back, why wasn’t he in a wheel chair”.
1:21 -
I’m on the subway back to my apartment. I’m trying to figure out what this whole experience has really meant to me. Was it profound? Was it supposed to be? Did we make the right decision? Was there a RIGHT decision? The thoughts of meaning keep cycling through my head, waiting for their true meaning to emerge. Meanwhile I’m considering a law degree that specializes in medieval justice practices.